EN
Menu

Rubber or textile car mats in winter?

The winter season in Lithuania poses serious challenges for the car interior – along with shoes, snow, water, mud and salt solutions get inside. Therefore, drivers face a dilemma as to which mats are better to use in winter: rubber or textile. There is no unequivocal answer – some choose rubber for practicality, others for comfort. In this article, based on Lithuanian climatic conditions and Lithuanian sources (expert advice, consumer reviews, forum discussions), we will compare rubber and textile mats according to several key criteria.

Protection against salts

In winter, Lithuanian roads are heavily salted, so the salt solution accumulating in the car can not only leave white spots, but also damage materials over time (e.g. carpeting or even the floor of the car body). When assessing the ability of mats to protect the interior from the effects of salts:
  • Rubber mats: Made of waterproof material, they do not allow salt solutions to reach the car floor – the liquid remains on the surface or in special grooves. Many rubber mats have raised edges and a deep pattern that traps water and dirt, preventing them from spreading into the cabin. This means that salt water does not soak into the mat itself, but collects on top, so it is easy to pour out or clean. It is important to note that a well-fitting rubber mat with high edges also protects the edges of the mat – water or dirt will not get outside the mat. This effectively protects the cabin from corrosion or stains caused by salts.
  • Textile mats: They absorb moisture into their fibers, so some of the salt solution is absorbed into the mat. High-quality textile models can absorb up to ~2 liters of water, depending on the price and thickness. At first glance, this is beneficial – fewer spots on the surface. However, such a wet mat can eventually allow moisture to reach the car’s floor carpeting, especially if it does not have an impermeable base. The result is damp interior carpets that do not dry for a long time and create conditions for rusting of metal parts. In addition, salts, absorbed into the textile fibers, leave white stains and destroy the mat material – the fabric can wear out faster, lose color and appearance. Drivers’ experience shows that without special cleaning, it is difficult to completely remove salt stains from textiles, and over time such a mat loses its attractiveness and functionality in winter.

Drying speed and moisture evaporation

In winter, mats are constantly in contact with snow and water, so it is important how quickly the material dries and whether it leaves excess moisture in the cabin, which can cause windows to fog up or an unpleasant odor:

  • Rubber mats: Water collects on the surface until you pour it out or it evaporates. Rubber mats themselves can be dried instantly after being removed from the car – usually it is enough to pour out the accumulated water and wipe it with a dry cloth. However, if water is left on the mat in the cabin, it can evaporate into the car interior. Rubber mats with high edges reduce the spread of moisture to some extent by retaining water in a certain area, but evaporation still occurs, especially in a warm cabin, and can increase fogging of the windows. Therefore, accumulated water should be poured out regularly. Compared to textiles, rubber does not get wet on its own – you will not have wet mats for a long time, which would have to be dried for hours.
  • Textile mats: Absorb moisture into their fabric, so they dry much longer. In winter, at low temperatures, a soaked mat can take a day or more to dry – especially if left in the car without additional drying in a warm room. During this time, the absorbed moisture evaporates into the cabin air: drivers notice that when using textile mats, moisture accumulates more often in the cabin – the windows fog up, and there is a musty smell of moisture. In addition, wet mats can freeze when they cool down (if the temperature drops below zero at night), and when the cabin is heated again – they can thaw again, thus repeating the cycle. Care tip: if you still use textile mats in winter, experts recommend drying them at least once a week – it is best to remove them and hang them in a warm, dry place. The ideal case is to have two sets and replace them regularly so that they dry completely.

Impact on footwear (effect of moisture and salt on shoes)

Another aspect is how the mat material affects the footwear itself. Will the shoes stay clean and dry, or will moisture and salts accumulate on the soles?

  • Rubber mats: Water and mud remain in the puddle on the rubber surface, so there is a risk that the foot will step into the same water again. If the mat is smooth or there is a lot of water, drivers notice that their shoes get wet with salt solution again. Therefore, it is recommended to choose rubber mats with grooves and a suitable pattern that direct water away from direct foot contact. A properly designed rubber mat will retain moisture in the curbs, so the sole of the shoe will rest on a drier surface between the grooves. Another aspect is safety and slipping: rubber mats are usually made with a non-slip, rough surface, so the foot should not slide on them much. However, cheaper, smoother rubber mats or plastic pads can become slippery, especially if there is a layer of water on top – this can make pedal control difficult. Some users mentioned on forums that rubber mats were slippery for them, and after switching to textile ones, their feet stand more firmly on the carpet.
  • Textile mats: Their surface is soft and porous, so the melting snow that initially soaks into them does not form a large puddle on the surface. This means that immediately after getting in, your shoes are standing on a relatively drier carpet – less direct contact with water and salt. Footwear slips less on textiles, because the material “hugs” the sole; even if snow gets in, it does not form a continuous puddle that forms a slippery film that you would feel under your foot. In this regard, a textile mat provides better grip for shoes and a more comfortable feeling. However, the problem arises later – when the mat is fully soaked. Then it becomes like a wet rag: when you step on it, water can seep back into the sole of the shoe or even into the shoes if there is a lot of moisture. If the mats are not cleaned in time, every time you get into the car, your shoes will come into contact with a damp, salty surface, which is unpleasant and can damage the footwear. It is recommended to clean/shake out such mats at least once every few days to prevent a mixture of dirt and salts from accumulating on the surface.

Aesthetics and cabin comfort

The appearance of a car’s interior is a subjective but important criterion for many. Floor mats are visible to everyone who gets in, so their material and design contribute to the overall impression:

  • Textile mats: Here they are the clear leaders in terms of aesthetics and a sense of luxury. Thick fabric, soft carpet mats give the interior a feeling of comfort and quality that rubber cannot replicate. It is no coincidence that high-quality textile mats are almost always used in luxury cars. Textile mats can be chosen from a variety of colors and designs, and they are easier to match with the interior decoration – a wide variety of options can be found on the market that match the interior of the car. Even for a mid-range car, a textile mat gives a more comfortable, “homely” feel. Drivers note that a cabin with fabric mats looks neater and more luxurious, especially if the mats are cleanly maintained. In winter, textile mats even provide a feeling of warmth – textile has a lower thermal conductivity than rubber, so it feels less cold to the touch (or even when you put your foot on it). Unfortunately, a dirty or salt-stained textile carpet quickly loses its beauty. It is difficult to keep it presentable in winter – moisture can leave stains, and constant wetting and cleaning wears out the material. So, although a new and clean textile carpet decorates the interior, at the end of the winter season it may look worse (longer pile, changed color, stains).
  • Rubber mats: Often considered less aesthetic. Many drivers agree that textiles are visually more attractive and luxurious. Rubber mats are usually black or dark, with limited design options (the coloring of rubber is complicated, so it is usually made in black, less often in gray or beige). For some, rubber mats remind them of the interiors of older, work-purpose cars. However, modern model rubber mats can look quite good: high-quality, 3D mats with a high border made exactly according to the shape of the cabin can fit into the interior and not catch the eye. A black rubber mat in a dark cabin visually blends in with the environment, especially if there are other black elements in the interior (e.g., a black steering wheel, dashboard) – then a black rubber mat will not spoil the overall look. In addition, in winter, cleanliness of the car interior often becomes a higher priority than luxury: it is better for the mat to be practical, even if it looks more modest. Some drivers note that model rubber mats (made for a specific car model) can look neat and even give a certain “sporty” feel to the interior. However, objectively speaking, textile wins in the aesthetics category – if the impression of luxury and comfort is most important, fabric mats have no equal. As a result, many drivers choose a compromise: in the cold season they lay rubber mats for comfort, and when spring comes, they replace them with textile ones so that they can enjoy a beautiful interior in the summer.

Ease of maintenance

Cleaning and maintenance – a practical aspect that determines how much effort will be required to keep the mats clean, especially in winter, when dirt and salt are constantly accumulating. The easier the maintenance, the more suitable the mats are for daily use in harsh conditions.

  • Rubber mats: This is their strong point. Rubber is dirt-resistant – everything stays on the surface, so even stubborn dirt is easily washed off with a jet of water. To clean, it is usually enough to remove the mats and wash them with plain water or wipe them with a damp cloth. Neither salt nor grease is absorbed into the rubber, so stains do not appear – salt deposits can be scrubbed or washed off without a trace. Sometimes, in the case of very heavy dirt, a mild detergent or brush can be useful, but this is rarely done. It is important to note that some rubber mats have a complex pattern (deep and narrow grooves) in which dirt can get stuck – they can be a little more difficult to clean (you need to rinse with a stronger jet of water or brush them), but it is still easier than removing entangled dirt from textiles. Rubber mats also last longer – their durability means that they do not need to be replaced often. Many drivers on the forum note that even cheap rubber mats last for more than one season, with minimal wear (sometimes the pattern only wears off at the sole). So in terms of maintenance, you just take them off, pour water over them, and they’re clean again.
  • Textile rugs: Their maintenance is much more complicated, especially in winter. Since the material absorbs dirt, you need to regularly vacuum the dust and sand so that they do not rub deep into the fibers. Even with frequent cleaning, over time, dirt penetrates deeper – the color of the carpet changes, stains appear. Plain water does not always help here: special carpet cleaners or shampoos, foams are often needed – after spraying them, you have to wait until the chemicals dissolve the dirt deep in the fibers, then scrub with a brush and pull it out with a vacuum cleaner or rags. Even after using a carpet cleaner, old stains may not be completely removed and the rug will not look like new. Salt is especially difficult to clean: salt residues “stick” to the carpet hairs, and in order to remove them, you need to soak in warm water or use a vinegar solution (a folk remedy) or special salt cleaners. This takes time and effort. In addition, after washing a fabric mat, it must be dried before use – and drying at room temperature can take, as mentioned, up to a day. A wet mat cannot be placed in the cabin. For these reasons, textile mats require more maintenance time in winter: almost daily vacuuming, frequent drying, regular washing. Drivers note that in winter they have to accept the fact that textile mats will still look dirtier, and they will most likely have to be replaced more often than rubber ones (they wear out faster from intensive cleaning and dirt friction).

The most important thing is to focus on your own needs.

If you care about maximum safety and cleanliness of the cabin, choose rubber mats; if aesthetics and comfort are your priority, you can leave textile mats for short trips in the winter. However, the majority of Lithuanian drivers tend to agree that practicality wins in the winter, so it is better to “shoe” the car with rubber mats for the winter season, and save textile mats for better weather. Such a choice will ensure that in the winter your car’s cabin will remain dry, clean and protected from the effects of salts, and in the spring you will be able to enjoy a neat and beautiful interior again.

Even such a seemingly small detail as properly selected floor mats in winter can really improve everyday driving comfort: less humidity in the cabin, less salts, fewer worries about maintenance. Similarly, with car insurance – when it is selected correctly, you feel calmer not only on the road, but also after it: it is clearer what and under what conditions would be compensated in the event of a traffic accident or damage. Read more about the most important nuances and choices of car insurance here: https://manramu.lt/transporto-draudimas/

More news